Supreme Court Watch: US v. Jones Decision
This morning, the Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision in United States v. Jones, which we covered in November. As a reminder, this case involved law enforcement officers surreptitiously installing a global positioning satellite tracking device on a suspect’s vehicle.
While the decision was unanimous, there were three differing opinions, ranging from Justice Scalia’s (the majority, and most moderate, opinion), to Justice Sotomayor’s.
The Court held that attaching such a device constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment, because it violates the suspect’s reasonable expectation of privacy. As such, a tracking device requires a warrant.
What was less clear was the details of just how far law enforcement officers can go before they need a warrant. Justice Scalia refused to comment on the reasonableness of the search itself, since the lower courts did not address that issue. For this reason, we can expect future cases to be argued before the Court, involving the intersection of GPS devices and reasonable suspicion.
- Supreme Court Unanimously Rejects Obama Administration’s Effort to Conduct Warrantless GPS Searches (jonathanturley.org)
- Breaking: SCOTUS Rules in Highly Anticipated GPS Tracking Case (abovethelaw.com)
- Supreme Court rules warrant needed for police GPS tracking (tarpon.wordpress.com)
- The Supreme Court struck down the U.S. government’s argument that it can use GPS to track a suspect’s vehicle without a warrant. (euzicasa.wordpress.com)
- Supreme Court unanimously rules warrants required for GPS tracking (venturebeat.com)
- Supreme Court rejects warrantless GPS tracking (geek.com)
- Supreme Court Ruled on GPS Tracking Case, Backs Privacy Rights (geodatapolicy.wordpress.com)
- Just decided: The Supreme Court decided in favor of nightclub… (shortformblog.tumblr.com)
- Supreme Court rules 9–0 that warrant absolutely needed for police GPS tracking (wired.com)
- Supreme Court says search warrants needed when police use GPS devices to track suspects (philammann.com)
- Supreme Court rules GPS tracking requires warrant (techradar.com)
- RT News-GPS spying: Supreme Court says police need a warrant (disclose.tv)
- Supreme Court: Warrant Needed For GPS Tracking (baltimore.cbslocal.com)
- Supreme Court Watch: Decisions in Hollingsworth v. Perry and Windsor v. United States
- Supreme Court Watch: Decision Monday
- What Fourth Amendment?
- Supreme Court Watch: Class Act Shun
- Supreme Court Watch: Decisions in FTC v. Actavis and Maracich v. Spears
- Supreme Court Watch: Voter Registration Edition
- Supreme Court Watch: Watershed Decision
- Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc. Decision
- The Match Game
- Courting Obstruction and Delay